New York’s art scene is a big part of its cultural identity, and art critics have real influence: their opinions can elevate an artist’s career or, in some cases, contribute to their obscurity. However, there is relatively few critics followed closely by artists. They are among them Pulitzer Prize-winning New York magazine critic Jerry Saltz and longtime co-art critic of the New York Times Roberta Smith. Married since 1992, they occupy a unique position in American culture as the most influential couple in contemporary art criticism.
At the Tribeca Film Festival, where the documentary was screened House of Criticism had its world premiere, the couple themselves became the object of attention. Directed by Alison Chernickwhose earlier films explored figures including Jeff Koons, Matthew Barney, Roy Lichtenstein AND Martin Margiela, House of Criticism lenses Saltz and Smith, exploring what it means to build a life within the intensely competitive cultural world of New York while remaining human.
“I’ve known Jerry and Roberta for about 20 years, and I’ve always been fascinated by their story,” Chernick told the Observer. “I wanted to reverse the usual dynamic and put them in front of the camera, making them the observed. Each of them came from imperfect beginnings and eventually found their way to New York, art and each other. For them, art became more than a profession; it became a form of survival, a language to understand themselves and the world around them. Their relationship naturally emerged as their emotional core.”
Rarely accessible, Chernick’s film follows their daily routines, their evolving views on art, and the role criticism plays in a world where everyone has an opinion. The film is both a love story and a reflection on taste, importance and honesty, as it reveals how professional distance can quietly complicate personal relationships within a close-knit artistic community.
While Saltz is the most recognizable public figure, Instagram personality and provocateur, Smith emerges as the film’s emotional anchor. Reserved and deeply focused on her work, she reveals a vulnerability that stands out as one of the documentary’s most compelling elements. The film strips away the authority often associated with the leading voice in art criticism, revealing something more human: uncertainty, ambition and lifelong commitment. It also captures the dynamic between the two critics, with Saltz repeatedly calling Smith the best art writer and critic, both on and off the screen.
“Every argument I’ve had with Roberta, she’s right, and I’m not kidding,” Saltz told the Observer. “I’ve tried to contribute to her work, hundreds of pieces, but I’ve never gotten anything because she’s, I think, the best she’s ever had.”
Their mutual admiration borders on competitive devotion. At times, the film reveals Smith’s quiet concern that Saltz’s writing might be stronger than hers, an unexpected uncertainty related by someone who spent nearly four decades writing at the highest level. But House of Criticism it is strongest when it moves beyond the mythology of the art world and into the personal stories that shaped its subjects.
Saltz’s social media followers know this His posts often move between art, politics and sex. The film embraces that irreverence. In an early scene, he recalls a teenage encounter with images of nude bodies that ignited his fascination with art. However, beneath the humor lies a deeper sadness. When Saltz was 10 years old, his mother died by suicide. He recalls a visit to the museum shortly before her death, recalling a remark he only understood years later. After she died, nothing was explained to him: there was no conversation, no room for grief and little recognition of what had happened. The silence about that loss stayed with him for decades.
Understanding that story makes a line in the film resonate differently: “Art saved my life,” Saltz says. “Looking at things takes me to another state of consciousness. Art is the greatest operating system our species has developed for understanding consciousness and the visible and invisible worlds.”
Set against an ever-changing New York, House of Criticism it is ultimately more than a film about criticism or cultural power. It is an intimate portrait of two people who found in art not only a profession, but a way to understand the world and each other. As Saltz says, art does not simply explain life. It makes life worthwhile.
More on Film Festivals
